Sponsored by Grouper.
Watch a video version of this tip on Instagram.
This is a classroom management trick that saved me multiple times. As a newer teacher, I would have moments when my classroom started to feel out of control — maybe I was giving instructions and too many students were talking over me, or I had started my students on an activity and too many of them were off-task. The room would be noisy — not in a good, productive way, but in a way that felt chaotic. As I scrambled to get control back, usually by redirecting or reprimanding individuals or small groups with little effect, I’d feel my heart start to race and I’d hear a voice in my head saying They don’t respect you.
And before I figured out this technique, when I reached that point I would just yell loud enough to jolt them into attention, followed by a few more angry directives. That would always get the job done — order would be restored, at least for a little while, but I hated how it made me feel. So … activated. And kind of embarrassed, honestly.
This happened maybe once every few weeks. But one day, and I don’t know what came over me, but instead of yelling I just grabbed a spiral notebook that was sitting on my desk. I dragged an empty student desk up to the front of the room, turned it around to face my students, sat down calmly, opened the notebook, and started writing. I said nothing at all, but I did glance up at them a few times, thinking about what to write next. And within 30 seconds, the class was completely silent. Watching me. Wondering what the heck I was writing.
And what was I writing? At first, I just vented. I wrote things I would never show anyone. Then I would eventually shift to description; I’d describe what was happening and what events led up to it, work backwards from that moment to see if I could figure out what had gone wrong that day. As I started using this practice more often, I would record the names of students who were actually behaving to remind myself that not all of them were acting up — that list was always longer than I expected it to be, and I would realize that ultimately it was just a few kids who were creating the chaos.
But really it didn’t matter what I wrote — the act of writing itself regulated my nervous system so I no longer felt the need to yell, and it got my students curious enough to get them to calm down too. After just a few minutes of this, I was often able to close the notebook and continue teaching as planned. No yelling, no office referrals, nothing.
This approach may not work for everyone, but it worked for me every time, so if you find yourself in a moment where you’re close to losing it, give it a try.
See all EduTips here.
Brilliant strategy! I plan to share this one with my student-teachers. Thank you!
Thank you so much for publishing and offering a me a constant reminder that there are educators that are amazing teachers, but can relate to the less than naturally endowed teachers. Your ‘out of control post’ reminds me informing students (as a substitute) that when I start talking fast or raise my voice they should give me the peace sign; if I catch myself doing the same, I’ll give it to you and it means I will calmly right down names and deal with individuals w/ whatever means is appropriate, usually I threat of a detailed note to the regular teacher was enough…and it empowered others to feel they had some control.
I’m curious if the effectiveness of this ever waned over time–did the students “catch on” to what you were doing, or get used to it, so that they eventually ignored it?
If they ever asked you what you were writing, what did you tell them?
I would imagine that like any strategy, you can’t use it all the time. Just a tool to keep in the toolbox. Also if a teacher did this and it had no effect whatsoever on the class, that would be concerning. Even the worst classes I’ve ever had in 10 years had SOME level of respect for me.
This resonates with me. I remember years ago suffering from the disruptive effects of one or two restless teens. My tactic then was to walk out of the classroom, quite dramatically, and return 15 seconds later with the notebook. Without saying a word I’d write things down, shooting a glance at the loud ones, then back at my notes. No threats, no raised voices, no particular sanctions, just a general warning that ‘the teacher isn’t happy with this!’ Worked a treat.
I plan on using this in my personal life!
Yes, this strategy could be useful in a variety of situations! Go for it!